Loading...

Aurelio's Pizza

About

  • 4.3 ( 50 reviews)
  • $$, $$$

What sets Aurelio's apart from other Chicago-style pizza? We're different because we use only quality ingredients, serve a variety of generous sizes, and specialize in customizing orders to suit each individual taste. Since 1959, the Aurelio family has been devoted to offering the finest pizza, pasta and sandwiches at reasonable prices with fast, courteous, dependable service. Come in today and grab a slice! Savor the tradition... At Aurelio's Pizza!

Day of the Week Opening Hours
Monday 16:00 - 22:00
Tuesday 16:00 - 22:00
Wednesday 16:00 - 22:00
Thursday 16:00 - 22:00
Friday 16:00 - 22:30
Saturday 16:00 - 22:30
Sunday 15:00 - 22:00

Cuisines

  • 🍝 Italian
  • 🍕 Pizza

Dining Options

  • 💺 Seating
  • 🥡 Takeout
  • 🍽️ Table service
  • 🍷 Serves Alcohol
  • 🚚 Delivery
  • 🍱 Lunch
  • 🍽️ Dinner

Recommended Reviews

5
68%
4
10%
3
14%
2
2%
1
6%
4.3
50 reviews
😕
Honest Lowell
2018-11-20 on google

Hope u dont mind nobody wearing gloves, and the most unprofessional rude management iv ever had the displeasure of talking to. The absolute worst part was having to swerve so I didnt hit the owner who thinks that they can park in the middle of the parking lot. I also like the people up front take my money go and cook without washing there hands. If I could give 0 stars I would.

😍
Aaron Bayus
2018-11-18 on google

Great staff. I order a pizza and it was not ready so they offer a free drink on the house for my wait. Customers come first here and there pizza is so good thanks again.

🙂
Bob Blankenstein
2018-11-12 on google

Quick service at carry out window. Good prices (with coupon). Smaller than average parking lot right off of busy Route 30. Not as good as Homewood original.... but close to home for a good pizza.

😍
Kathy Johnson
2018-08-23 on google

I love Aurelio's pizza and this location did not disappoint. The building itself has a very interesting layout that adds to the classic pizza joint ambiance. I would definitely visit again when in the area.

😍
Scott Strain
2018-07-25 on google

Best pizza I ever had Love this place.

😐
Ashourrina Henshaw
2018-07-22 on google

Let me be clear that this 2 stars is VERY specific to this location only. A few weeks ago I went here and the pizza was great, yesterday I went and it seems like their recipe changed. The salad dressing was basically oil and bland. Not like their normal house Italian dressing. I get the same antipasta salad and cheese pizza every time and I was very disappointed. The sauce, cheese, and crust was all different. It was paper thin and soggy. Not their normal crust at all. If they changed their recipe, between that and the subpar customer service, I will not come back to this location. The pizza didn’t even look very appetizing.

😍
Morgen Benner
2018-07-08 on google

The best pizza in the region. Lots of delicious, high quality toppings and cheese. The sauce is just a little sweet, but very good.

😍
Keith M
2018-05-23 on google

Great pizza, nice crispy crust, friendly staff.

😍
L G
2018-05-06 on google

This place is great. The service is awesome here and the food is great. I recommend getting “the works” pizza you will not regret it. I don’t think there is anything bad on their menu. This place is very cozy to have a pizza and beer. I definitely will be returning to Aurelio’s Pizza.

🙂
Gabriel Aluisy
2018-04-23 on google

Fair pizza. Salad was pretty poor. Staff was friendly, but a little slow.

🙂
Cdubs
2018-04-16 on google

It felt crowded in there and the pizza didn’t taste the same as the Homewood Aurelio’s.

🙂
Pifase
2018-04-08 on google

Food was Excellent! Restrooms however were extremely small.

😀
aniya
2018-01-25 on google

Pizza was okay as others but chicken Alfredo pasta was great. Will try their other pastas next time.

😍
Jeffrey Brookes
2018-01-20 on google

Great pizza and service

😍
Dawn Kush
2018-01-16 on google

Best pizza in Northwest Indiana! Quality and service..we have been getting our pizzas from here for over 36 years now! Great tip is to get your pick up pizza "uncut", cut it when you get home, this makes the pizza crust still crispy- because the cheese and sauces have not seeped between the slices!

😍
Brett Williamson
2018-01-10 on google

Awsome pizza and antipasto salad

😍
Tom Pozywio
2017-10-12 on google

Great pizza! Slightly sweet sauce. Normal crust was crisp. Service was pleasant. Small beer selection, no Stouts which was disappointing for me but most will be happy with the selection. Very kid friendly

😍
Chris Hinshaw
2017-09-18 on google

What a great place to eat at A+++

😍
Chris Johnson
2017-09-16 on google

Aurelio's Pizza is not to be compared to California pizza. This is Northwest Indiana Region pizza, and outside of Chicago style deep dish pizza, Aurelio's Pizza stands out as a favorite. Aurelio's serves outstandingly tasty pizza and other Italian favorites. Please try it!

😍
Traci Studer
2017-08-21 on google

We celebrated my Grandmas 95th birthday...it was a great time with great food

😍
Clark Szabo
2017-08-15 on google

Best Aurelio's franchise around! No skimping on ingredients like others, real pizza ovens makes a difference.

🙂
John Boersma
2017-07-10 on google

Aurelios pizza is a great regional pizza place. But the Dyer location isn't the best (yes, pizza tastes different at each location!) and the building itself is in desperate need of renovation. Not 100% sure how it's ok to have to go down stairs for a restroom, and having a urinal too close to the sink without a screen is gross.

😍
robert E
2017-07-10 on google

One of my all time favorite pizza places!! Aurelios is the best.

😍
Patrick Lydon
2017-05-24 on google

Aurelio's pizza isn't cheap but worth it!

😍
Pat Murphy
2017-04-27 on google

Picked up and had to wait. But it was well worth it. Delicious super 6 pizza!

😍
tim felus
2017-04-26 on google

Not cheap but best pizza around

😍
Dan Terpstra
2017-04-19 on google

The food is as good as the service.

😍
Kellan Faulkner
2017-04-18 on google

Would certainly recommend eating here. Awesome mood, delicious food, great customer service. They never disappoint.

😀
Michelle McDermott
2017-04-02 on google

Good, but not as good as Munster location.

😕
Rick Adney
2017-02-12 on google

Have always loved sauce. Had great pizza from this location. Been there many times. Tonight worst! Didn’t get what I ordered. Hardly close. Ok. I can eat any pizza. No. Sauce not good. Pizza not good. They offered free pizza but if like today I’m not sure I want it. Hoping a one time bad experience.

😍
Jeff P
2017-02-07 on google

We are from northwest indiana and have enjoyed Aurelio's all our life. So glad there is one near Indy! Need one in Greenwood!

😍
Mary Tyler
2017-01-14 on google

Wonderful staff and service! I ordered food for 40 people for my rehearsal dinner off their catering menu and had the best service. They truly went above and beyond to make sure we'd have everything we'd need. The manager called the day before it was to be delivered to ensure the order was correct and walk through anything additional we'd need (plates, extra butter, other condiments, etc.). Delivery was exactly on time and staff was wonderful. And off course the food was delicious, everyone at the dinner raved about how good it was. I would absolutely recommend this location, especially for any catering needs!

😍
Heather Rivera
2017-01-06 on google

Yum! This place has the best deep dish pizza.

😀
G. Kevin Wright
2016-11-12 on google

Good food and service...we will go back!

😍
Dominick Bruno
2016-10-04 on google

Hands down the best thin crust pizza in the Chicago area. There's just something about slight sweetness and tiny spice to the sauce that I long for whenever I have pizza someplace else. If you think sauce makes the pizza (which it does) Aurelio's is your place.

😍
Ms CareBear Trucker
2016-09-06 on google

I never thought i would stop here, but i am now a fan. We walked in, 1st thing that hit us was a bad smell of old mop water ( not good). We was seated and ordered a 1/2 sausage 1/2 pepperoni that was tasty and crunchy thin Judy how i liked it. A side salad to match, but the dressing was not so good. She brought me this large side salad, that's good but it was on a small plate food was spulling from the sides. The French dressing had some kind of pineapples in it, i should have been told that first. The bathroom is a 1 door, 1 stall place not good. But since they are a pizza joint, the pizza was AMAZING, I'll probably go back just for a carry out tho.

😍
Barb Markle
2016-09-02 on google

This is the pizza I would want in a deserted island. Our go to favorite, sometimes opting for this instead of a fancy occasion dinner. This location like Homewood has the old wood pizza oven. Pizzas at other Aurelio’s locations are good, but not Schererville/Homewood great! Love it!

😍
Natalie Ladd
2016-08-26 on google

The thin crust pizza is some of the best. Generous with the toppings and excellent sauce.

😍
Real W
2016-08-10 on google

Awesome fresh food ..thanks for being wonderful. And the best chicken wings . hospitality is A. + + +

😀
Shannon Bradley
2016-06-17 on google

I really like this Aurelio's. But last night they gave our pizza to another customer. They didn't say nothing to us. Just your pizza will be here shortly. We finally questioned our waiter and finally told us. We got our pizza about 7 minutes later. It was good and hot. But it did upset use a little bit.

😍
Shelby Cates
2016-06-16 on google

We always have a good time here, great food! The last time though, the service was lacking. Our waitress pulled a Houdini. We had a party of 12, had to wait a while to get a refill on our beverages. The drinks were finally refilled as we finished our food. Other than that it was great.

😀
Don H
2016-05-09 on google

Pizza was very good. They need to add a few more phones to the operation. Had to call multiple times and got many busy signals. On this busy night took a long time for pizza to arrive.

😍
Jessica Aghimien
2016-05-05 on google

Great pizza 👌

😍
Annabel Muscarella
2016-05-02 on google

Pepperoni pizza the best in town.

😍
Deborah Lockette
2016-03-17 on google

We recently ordered a sausage and pepperoni pizza for carry out. It was out of this world delicious!! The pizza we ordered the very next day was as good, if not better!! I would even venture to say it's the best pizza I've ever had!!!

🙂
Demarie Elle
2016-03-16 on google

Lately they haven’t been cooking the pizza all the way. The last time I got a vegetarian pizza and the veggies were completely raw. The next time I ordered plain cheese and pepperoni and it still wasn’t cooked all the way. Needless to say I get terrible heart burn and indigestion from this pizza so I only eat it once in a blue moon. But every time I regret it because of how it makes me feel.

😍
Hamza Nelson
2016-03-08 on google

This place is fantastic! Affordable rates, big dishes and the staff members are regularly very friendly.

🙂
Suzzanne Arnold
2016-02-27 on google

The pizza did not seem evenly cooked. Part of the pizza, a small edge was crispy. The rest of the pizza was under cooked evidenced by a soft crust.

😕
Hillary Goranowski
2016-01-24 on google

If you do order from here, pick it up or you will die of starvation. Delivery service is the worst it can get and definitely not worth a 2+ hour wait.

😍
AMY CERVANTES
2016-01-14 on google

We want there after a funeral, they opened early for us to accommodate our large group. Kim was helpful and patient working with the the large group.

Questions & Answers

Per their FB page post on May 17th: I would like to take a moment to thank everyone that has supported us during these trying times. It is a scary time for everyone and we truly appreciate everyone one of you. Because of that appreciation, we have decided that we will not be opening dine-in on May, 18th. It comes with tough deliberation, however the confidence and safety of our customers and staff cannot be compromised. Thank you for your continued support and patience, we are eager to serve you again.

Giordanoes does.

Yes

Yes
Top